Spiegel Online have a rightfully indignant opinion piece on the slippery slope Europe is navigating in its treatment of muslim communities:
It took the Catholic Church 359 years to revoke its condemnation of Galileo, but the current Pope needed only two days to distance himself from his quotation of a statement that remains topical despite being uttered 500 years ago. Piet Hein Donner, the former Dutch Minister of Justice, who has just resigned from her [sic] position, believes Islamic Shariah law could be legally introduced in Holland if two thirds of the Dutch population were to one day approve it. The London police has announced it will inform and consult with a board of Muslim community leaders the next time it plans an anti-terrorism operation that affects Muslims.
Let’s be clear: in a secular democracy everybody deserves respect and equal treament before the law, and nobody should be afforded special rights or consideration. If the day to day functions of a Western state require actions that might offend the muslim community, that’s just tough luck.
What set the Spiegel off was the pre-emptive scrapping of Mozarts opera Idomeneo, which was set to be performed at the Deutsche Oper in Berlin. Germany’s Office of Criminal Investigation (LKA) decided that “the possibility of performances being disrupted cannot be ruled out”, because of a scene where Idomeneo, the King of Crete, appears on stage with a bloody bag containing the heads of Poseidon, Jesus, Buddha and Mohammed. Idomeneo, to add insult to injury, holds the heads aloft for all to see.
Now, if Mohammed feels insulted because he was mocked, maligned or manhandled, get him to fight his own battle. The same goes for Poseidon, Jesus and Buddha, and unless they can prove they’re tax-paying residents of said Western democracy, they have no say in how the place is run. Cancelling an already scheduled opera (and opera, as painful as it can be, is still an important part of the European cultural heritage) means caving to religious pressure.
Despite sometimes violent objections, Madonna did not cancel a single one of the performances in which she was mock crucified on stage. Why? Because she wasn’t doing anything illegal, she offered a show where the audience wasn’t forced to attend, and she was simply exercising her right to free speech. Or song.
Religious extremism in Europe will come to a head sooner or later. It will not simply fade away. The longer religious communities pressure society and government for special consideration, the more the European electorate will drift towards the right and fall into an “us and them” mindset. This will only allow the religious extremists to claim oppression, and will further polarise the situation. Avoiding this scenario will require sacrifice from the religious communities, not from secular society.
Popularity: 17% [?]